As I'm writing this, it's August 15, the Feast of the Assumption, when the Blessed Virgin Mary was assumed body and soul into Heaven. If you're reading it the day it's published, however, it's October 15, the day when we commemorate the passing of millions of other souls into eternal life, Pregnancy and Infant Loss Remembrance Day. It is a day that has particular meaning to me, as my beloved wife has had four miscarriages: one from her first marriage and three with me.
This Halloween, we will remember the sixth anniversary of one of them, probably the most difficult one for either of us emotionally. It was one that I just began to come to terms with this year, thanks to plenty of prayer, therapy and an article I read, entitled, "
How to Have a Miscarriage." I had seen it posted in a Facebook support group for fathers of miscarried children, and my first thought was not to click on it, thinking it dealt with how to trigger one naturally. After a few days of the link taunting me, however, I decided to click on it. The resulting read was one that triggered a surge of anger, grief and guilt expressed in incoherent sobs almost seven years after the fact. It wasn't due to the similarities to my wife's experience, but rather, due to the differences.
There were some similarities initially. My wife, like the woman in the article, was 40. We weren't trying, though. We had just had a son January of that year, and we figured that was just freak luck. We never expected another conception in general, much less the same year, yet there we were late that summer, marveling at our above average fertility. We weren't anything resembling wealthy, so we were understandably nervous about finances, but knowing our families would express more than enough verbal concern about that for both of us, I simply kissed her tummy and whispered, "Welcome," to the tiny person in there.
Around mid-October, things changed. My wife's asthma, which usually became negligible during pregnancy, started to return to non-pregnancy levels. Time went by, and spotting started. We went in to the obgyn to get her looked at, praying, full of fear for our little girl. My wife's regular obgyn was out, not a situation you want to be in when miscarrying. It was too early for any ultrasound to show gender, but instinct told us both she was carrying a girl, and her instincts have never been wrong for any live births, so I trust those same instincts regarding any miscarriages. It was late enough for an ultrasound to detect a heartbeat, or lack thereof in this case. I was there with my wife, our nine-month old son, and the little girl we prayed was all right. When I saw the image on the ultrasound, that little baby looked perfect. Although based on timing, the fetal age should've been thirteen weeks, the ultrasound said eleven. There was no possible way to soften the words from the doctor that day, "I'm not finding a heartbeat." She sent us to Overlook Hospital for a second ultrasound, just in case, but her tone told me she didn't hold out much hope. On the drive over, to hell with New Jersey law in that situation, I called my Dad. I asked for his prayers, cried with him and asked him to let others know.
When we arrived, they did the second ultrasound, same results, and they scheduled my wife for a D&C to remove our little child's body. This was where things were very different from the Hairpin article. We didn't hear about any other options. We didn't hear that we could go home and wait for things to occur naturally, which, as you will soon read, probably would've happened sooner rather than later.
As we were walking, yes, walking, to the area where the procedure would be done, we experienced the one time that day when we were entirely alone. People being discharged from a hospital stay, who have no need of any assistance moving, are still sometimes wheeled out in wheelchairs, but my miscarrying wife was expected to walk. It was in a hallway, and at that moment was when spotting went to actual hemorrhaging. Having known the fear due to my wife hemorrhaging after labor had been induced during the last pregnancy, I felt a fear like I had never known before, the fear of losing both. The next...I don't even know how long it was...I don't remember what happened. Whether help arrived, or I carried, dragged or walked her there, I still don't know. All I know is that we got where we needed to go.
While we waited, I called our pastor. I'm the type that many non-Catholic or non-practicing Catholic friends often ask when a question about what the Catholic Church does in the case of this or that, but I had no idea what Catholic procedure was in the event of a miscarriage, which our pastor could probably tell. While we waited for him, a chaplain who was part of the hospital staff prayed with us. Our pastor arrived, and they prayed together, and then he prayed a prayer that's used for miscarriages. That was the one moment of comfort that occurred the whole day.
When the surgeon who would be doing the procedure arrived, we requested that he keep our baby's remains so we could have a burial. His cold response was, "Well, I can preserve the specimen, but there won't be much left." The specimen? My baby was reduced to that? As my tongue recovered from the shock enough to begin shaping into the first expletive in what would have been a tapestry of them if I had gotten the chance, my wife fired back, "That is not a specimen; that is my daughter!" The doctor's response was a weak, "As you wish."
The procedure began, and I waited with my nine month old. I had to watch as life went on around me. Although it was a hospital, and they were dealing with sick and injured people, there was still a bit of a festive, celebratory feel about the place, as it was Halloween. While they passed candy around and talked about their plans, I waited, my plans, hopes and dreams for my little girl shattered. It felt so wrong that life should be allowed to continue for the rest of the world, and that I should be forced to witness it, all while my wife and I grieved. After what seemed like forever, the doctor notified me he was finished, and he let me know there was genetic testing that could be done to verify gender and to see if there were any physical problems that resulted in the miscarriage. We didn't have the money for that, and knowing wouldn't bring her back, so I declined.
A little later, I was told my wife was awake, and I could come see her. However, as I headed in with my son to the area of recovery where she was, the nurse behind the desk informed me in a near shout, "Excuse me, you can't bring the baby in here!" I snapped back, "Well, it would be nice if somebody told me that before telling me I could go see my wife who just miscarried! I don't have anybody with me to watch the baby!" As I left that area, a few of the other nurses who were around enough to know who I was and what my wife had just been through offered to watch my son while I went in. As I headed back in empty handed, I approached the nurses' station to ask where my wife was. The nurse who was there at that point then said I couldn't see her and asked me when she was getting out. "How the hell should I know? You're the ones who are supposed to know that!" was the first thing I could say. At that point, I was very worried about my wife, as I was wondering if, like me, she had been told I could see her and was wondering why I wasn't there yet, and livid at the conflicting instructions I was being given. I began to storm out ranting about why I wanted to see her so badly, and for them to come find me when they figure out what their policies and procedures were supposed to be. At last, someone showed me a little compassion and told me where my wife was. She looked miserable, but relieved to see me, and all I could think to do was hold her until I headed back out.
We left the hospital that same day, and I dropped my wife at home to rest. The day was nowhere near over yet for me. Death in the family or not, it was still Halloween. The older kids, ranging in age from eleven to fifteen at the time, were getting together with friends, and it was my son's first Halloween. Life was expected to go on, and I was expected to run it. The afternoon and evening were a blur, but trick or treating happened, and we have pictures of my son in his giraffe costume from that day, and I'm sure everybody ate. Nighttime came, and I came to bed. The one person who had the most right not to consider how I was feeling at the moment asked me if I was okay. If ever I have lied in my marriage, my yes was probably it that night. The truth was, as I drifted off to sleep that night, I truly wanted to die. I wanted to close my eyes, go to sleep and not wake up the next morning, and if there had not been a wife and kids on earth who still needed me, I probably could have. Their need for me was the thin thread on which hung my belief that life was still worth living, so I woke up the next morning, numb and going through the motions.
As months and years went on, I still ached each year on Halloween, finding it hard to celebrate, but the focus of my thoughts was that at least my little baby was safe in Our Lord's arms, until I found out something I had never known in the immediate aftermath. My wife had been experiencing extreme guilt over what happened that day, as a D&C is not only used after a miscarriage, but as a common surgical abortion procedure. It should be noted that ultrasound and other technology have made it much easier to confirm fetal death, as was the case with us, so there is a clear difference between removing the already expired baby and an abortion. Still, given our staunch pro-life beliefs, the similarity haunted my wife for a long time until she had taken the time to process the experience through
EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization Reprocessing) therapy. Even after that, finding out the hell she went through for years, about which I was completely clueless, sent me through my own spiral of guilt. I went through a process unofficially known as "shoulding" on myself. I should've been able to fight for her the day of the miscarriage; I should've known more about our options; I should've insisted on a wheelchair or stretcher to take her across the hospital; I should've known she was having such a hard time afterwards. After EMDR therapy, she was doing a lot better, and in many ways I felt reassured. We were able to celebrate and have fun again last year when Halloween hit. As has become a tradition, she took the day as a personal day, and we went to see our little boys (yes, we had one more born after the miscarriage) at their school Halloween parades. I felt safe asking if they were playing Halloween music on Music Choice's "Sounds of the Season" channel (suggestion if anyone who decides the programming is reading this: add "Frankenstein" by Edgar Winter this year). We cut the pumpkins the night before. We had fun. As my wife began to heal, I formed a scab and thought I was okay, but I wasn't.
That Hairpin article ripped the scab from me, and I was bleeding again, as fresh and raw as if it had just happened. I've been through EMDR to process other traumatic events in my life, and although my next therapy session after reading that article was not EMDR specifically, there was an outpouring that I can say was very similar. I relived it, dug down deep as I knew I had to do, and I processed my grief and anger at last. I was able to let go of things about that day for which I had long blamed myself, and that my wife was since able to tell me, "I survived." I felt like I finally had a right to recover. I still ache sometimes to see my little girl. I ache to hold her. I look forward to seeing her in Heaven when my time is done here, but I don't beg for it. I believe that life is worth living for as long as I'm here, and however long or short that is, I know I will see my little saints I never got to hold in this life.
I wouldn't say I reached that point even immediately after that therapy session. It has been insanely busy, without much time to rest, and therefore not much time to "process the processing" I did at therapy. It hasn't had the opportunity to set fully, and I got to thinking, maybe that's because I haven't shared it yet. It hit me that maybe that was the last piece of the puzzle I needed, to share my story, so that other men could not have to experience what I did. Why write it now but wait to post it? Well, now is when I'm thinking about it, while October, when there are miscarriage awareness events and posts all over social media, is when the population in general might notice it more. I suppose I'm thinking strategically for maximum benefit for others. Maybe the fact that the youngest of the girls in my beautiful blended family just left for college the day I wrote it, so I feel a fresh sense of loss that won't be here when this posts. All my girls on earth are, whether by blood or as a bonus of marriage, are legally adults now, even though they'll always be my little girls in my heart.
Sometimes fathers feel they are not allowed to grieve, that since they didn't have the physical loss that mothers experience, they're expected not to hurt on the inside. It's sometimes not even acknowledged by organizations that are supposed call attention to miscarriage and infant loss. I can remember one group having symbols to post to one's Facebook profile. They had one for mothers, and they had one for friends of those mothers who had experienced miscarriage, but not one for fathers. I can't even find the website anymore, so I have no idea if they've updated their assortment to let hurting daddies in on it, but even without a picture, I hope friends of couples suffering the loss of miscarriage will think of us too. Definitely don't do anything less for the women who suffer this grief, but after you've done all you can to comfort a grieving mother, take a moment, take the father aside, and ask him, "How are you holding up?" I assure you, it makes a world of difference. If you are a father dealing with miscarriage or infant loss or know someone who is, here are some helpful links:
Also, if you'll indulge me, a few songs that, for one reason or another, have some meaning in relation to that sad day. Feel free to listen:
I Knew I Loved You
Another Day
I Can Only Imagine
Here's to Us - Language alert, but when I heard it a few years ago on Halloween, the takeaway for me was that it was ok simultaneously to mourn those I lost and celebrate those I have